711

711
ELA Ms. Cunningham

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

"Building Bridges" Essay By Emma Crowley

“You got big hopes child, but they gonna leave me alone, by myself”
This reminds us that parents or grandparents have a hard time letting someone they are really close to leave them to go follow their dreams. The short story “Building Bridges” by Andrea Pinkney is about a teenage girl named Bebe and her grandmother Mama Lil. In the story, Bebe really wants to be an engineer. Andrea Pinkney portrays in the story that Mama Lil is reluctant to let Bebe go follow her dreams as an engineer. Through the story the author wants the reader to know that Bebe and Mama Lil’s relationship is complex and yet kind of like our relationships with our parents and grandparents too.
In the story Mama Lil can’t seem to let Bebe go.

First, Mama Lil just hated the idea and the answer was simply NO. In the beginning of the story Mama Lil was doesn't want to let Bebe go.  For example as Mama Lil was sitting down smoking her cigarette she said “Ain’t no black woman doing no engin-ing” page 21 . The reader infers that this shows that Mama Lil doesn’t accept Bebe’s dream of engineering doing and doesn’t really seem to care. The reader also comes across this idea of that Mama Lil is using her real life experiences to believe that race dictates the type of job you can and can not do.  Also she doesn’t even care enough to say engineering correctly.  Another example is in this quote where Bebe is trying to talk Mama Lil into letting her do the Brooklyn Bridge project Bebe says, “Mama Lil, your eyes are always closed, closed to seeing me” page 28.  At this part the reader thinks Mama Lil won’t pay attention or cooperate with Bebe. The reader then assumes that this is because she doesn’t want to sign the papers because she doesn’t want to let Bebe go. This also shows the reader that Mama Lil doesn’t want Bebe to leave her so therefore she wont truly look at Bebe and doesn’t even try to understand Bebe’s hopes and dreams.  Another example of this is that while Bebe was describing the kind of relationship they have and what they say about/to each other she says “She [Mama Lil] thought I weighted too much, and dressed badly.” page 18. This shows the reader that Mama Lil isn’t afraid to tell Bebe how she feels. This can be good and bad, it means they have a good, trusting relationships, or that they are kind of mean to each other. But, when they are mean to each other it can cause feelings to get hurt, it really depends on what they say and how they say it. Something like this might have happened to many people with their families and/or friends. But if they are so close that they can say these things to each other then the reader becomes a bit confused when in the middle of this story Mama Lil has trouble telling Bebe how she truly feels about this Bridge project…
In the end of the story Mama Lil opened her eyes and realized what was best for Bebe and she let her go live out her dream. Everyone knows “If you love something let them go, and if they love you to, they will come back.” At the end of the story when Mama Lil finally approves Bebe’s dream she says to Bebe “ Bebe, the bridge is lucky to have you.” page 34. This quote shows that Mama Lil really does care and love Bebe and even though she doesn’t want to let Bebe go, she still respects her decision and loves her.  Another thing is that when Mama Lil is explaining to Bebe why she doesn’t want Bebe to go work on the bridge project she says, “ [Bebe] Your dreams are the kind that’ll take you away from here” page 29. This shows that the only reason why she didn’t want to let Bebe go is that she didn’t want Bebe to leave her all alone with nobody.  Mama Lil then says, “what little bit of dreaming I got left… I’m putting to you.” page 29. Mama Lil loves Bebe and she wanted her to be the best she can be. Something that Mama Lil knew she didn’t do.  Mama Lil shows her true colors here.  Mama Lil loves Bebe and always will. She never wants to let her go but she realized that the best thing to do for Bebe is let her shine and be the best that she can be.  So therefore Mama Lil gave in and said yes to let Bebe follow her dreams.
Throughout the story Mama Lil changed her whole demeanor. She went from being reluctant to let Bebe leave her to realizing allowing Bebe to follow her dreams was best. Mama Lil started out not being truthful or honest with Bebe or how she truly felt about this project. She is telling her that she wouldn’t sign the permission slip because she was a black woman. She even says to Bebe “ If God had made you to do a man’s work he would’ve made you a man” page 20. She starts to come up with any possible excuse to stop Bebe from doing this. As we read through the story we see a change in Mama Lil. This is that she starts being more truthful with Bebe and tells her why she really didn’t want her to do the project. She didn’t want to be alone. Mama Lil says to Bebe “ Your dreams are the kind that’ll take you away from here.” page 29.  The thought of losing Bebe was the only reason she didn’t want to sign the form. Bebe is determined to do this job. “Mama Lil I got to find my own way” page 29. Even though Mama Lil doesn’t want Bebe to leave her it doesn’t get in Bebe’s way of doing her dream- this is important.

In the end the reader sees that relationships can be hard and complicated. We see this through the way Mama Lil starts out reluctant to letting Bebe go. Or this even shows in her decision to let Bebe go to follow her dreams. It can be hard to let go of someone you’re so close to. I can relate to this. I have Family in Ireland. I only see the two weeks every two years. So when I see them but then I  have to go back to America it’s hard for me. I just can’t let them go. This can help me understand how Mama Lil is feeling. Andrea Pinkney shows this very well in the way she created Mama Lil as a person. Through the story the author wants the reader to know that Bebe and Mama Lil’s relationship is complex and yet kind of like our relationships with our parents and grandparents too. In the story Mama Lil can’t seem to let Bebe go. I think that Bebe and Mama Lil will make this work and always have each other no matter what. Sometimes we feel resistant to letting go of someone you care for so much but when you love someone you have to let them go.

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

My Name

          My name means whole, entire, and universal woman in German. To me, this means I'm not shy.  I'm 

outgoing and well... universal.  My name is a BRIGHT color.  This suits me- I love bright colors, they make me 


stand out.


Emma


          My name is the number 4- not one to forget.  4 can fit into a lot of other numbers, making me confident in 

fitting in with others.  This is my lucky number because my middle name also has four letters in it-


Rose


          My middle name Rose, is the Blessed Mother's flower.  I like that. I like it because it shows that I'm catholic. 

I'm not afraid to be myself and show others the type of person I am.  It's nice to show that in my name.


Emma


          My mom and dad didn't originally choose Emma.  In fact it was last minute.  My mom wanted to call me 

Courtney but my dad wanted to call me Laura.  This changed when they saw me- they knew I would be the 


perfect Emma. 


And I'm glad they did.


Emma


          My name rhymes with dilemma.  Dilemma is a problem.  I make mistakes.  Lots of them.  This makes me 

think that I'm the only imperfect problem in this world.  But I'm only human and humans aren't perfect  even 

though I want to be.  And as I go through life I realize, so does everyone else.  But all we can do is try.

Emma


          If I wasn't Emma I wouldn't be the same person I am today (just with a different name).  My name shaped 

me to be the person I am today.  I wouldn't want to change my name.  Ever.  It suits me.  Everyone has 

something that makes them special. 

For me it's being what I am best-


Emma.

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

The Lightning Thief?

The Lightning Thief
By Rick Rordan

          The Lightning Thief by Rick Rordan is a book about a boy named Percy Jackson. His life didn't start out so well at first. His mom was struggling with money, his mom's boyfriend was a pig, and he was not doing well in school. But one day something came up and he had to go to this mysterious camp. Percy had no idea about. It was a camp for half bloods:

  • Half goat/human
  • Half god/human
Percy was  at the same time excited when he found out his father was Posiden the god of water. He goes on an adventure with his friends Grover and Annabeth to find Zeus' stolen master bolt. In the end, (*SPOILER ALERT*) Luke, one of the camp counselors and percy's "friend", stole the bolt. 

But the movie says otherwise...
When you finish reading this you will know why you should most definitely read the book before the movie.


          One reason why you should read the book before watching the movie is the characters said, acted, and looked different in the movie than they did in the book. For example Annabeth is supposed to be blond. She is also supposed to have an invisibility cap to help them get out of trouble during the quest. Of course the movie HAD to change that. They took it out! Another example is that Grover is not supposed to be outgoing and brave. In fact he is supposed to be shy and scared. I don't know if changing this was supposed to make the story more dramatic or something but it would have been better to keep it the same. A final example is the change in what Percy's mom does.  In the book she leaves Posiden and stays with Hades to show her independence.  In the movie Grover stays behind instead of her.  This shows that the characters have been changed in the movie.

          Another reason why you should read the book before watching the movie is that the movie changed the adventure!!!!! One example is that the whole adventure in the book is supposed to be percy and his friends are looking for Zeus' stolen matter bolt. In the movie the adventure is trying to find pearls that will help them escape hell. Those pearls are in the book but they are a gift from posiden NOT THE WHOLE QUEST!!!!!!!!Another example is that Clarisse (daughter of Ares) is supposed to fight percy. in fact she is supposed to attack percy and cut him which is when he finds out is after is Posiden. In the movie CLARISSE NOR ARES ARE IN THE MOVIE!!!!! A final example is that Hades isn't supposed to die!!! in the movie for drama they made persephone kill hades, which can't ever happen. this proves why the adventure was changed too much.

          A final reason why you should read the book before watching the movie is that its better to imagine the characters and places yourself. One example is that if you read the book after you have already watched the movie you will imagine the characters the way they looked in the movie.  You don't get to do your own envisioning when reading it.  Another example is that its better to see what others think the characters and places look like after you have imagined how they look.  You can compare how you imagined with how they are portrayed in the movie.   And finally its fun to imagine things on your own. Its fun to see what possible things you could think of but if you watch the movie first you don't get that experience.  This shows that it's better to imagine these things on your own.

          In conclusion you should read the book before watching the movie even for any book because it makes you a stronger thinker.   For one reason you imagine what things look like and two, you can find the differences and similarities in the movie and book.  All in all if they were going to change the book The Lightning Thief to make it a movie then don't call it The Lightning Thief.